Why AI Personalization Is Stuck in Pilot Mode

In Part 2 of the 2025 CX Benchmark Series, we explore a growing tension at the heart of modern customer success strategy: a collective conviction in the transformative potential of AI, tempered by a stark absence of real-world deployment. Our research reveals a pattern both familiar and concerning. While 72% of CS leaders describe AI as “critical” to their future, just 32% report running even a single live use case, and only 3% characterize their adoption as “extensive.” The implications are clear: belief in AI’s promise remains high, but execution lags far behind.

This phenomenon, what we refer to as the AI Confidence Gap, is not rooted in technical shortcomings alone. Rather, it reflects a deeper organizational reality: personalization, the most valued outcome of AI, is not a product of algorithms alone. It is the result of alignment, between systems, data, workflows, and above all, trust.

The Plateau of Pilots: Why Experimentation Stalls

Today, many CS organizations find themselves locked in a cycle of evaluation without execution. 31% are actively assessing AI tools, and another 31% are piloting specific use cases. Yet few move beyond this early experimentation. We refer to this stasis as Pilot Paralysis, a condition where AI remains perpetually in testing, rarely advancing to full-scale integration. The root cause? Most pilots live on the periphery of actual work. They are constructed as proofs of concept, rather than embedded within core workflows. Without tangible impact, trust doesn’t accumulate. And without trust, teams are understandably hesitant to scale.

{{benchmarks-report}}

Diagnosing the Real Barrier: Data, Not Dollars

When asked what prevents further progress, the expected culprits, budget constraints, limited headcount, and lack of executive sponsorship, did not top the list. Instead, one factor stood out across regions and segments: data quality. In organizations where customer data remains fragmented across CRMs, product logs, support tools, and spreadsheets, AI is left without the necessary context to generate reliable insight. The result is not insight, but noise. As one operations leader succinctly observed, “Data quality is destiny.” Without trustworthy, unified inputs, even the most advanced AI fails to deliver value. Scale, ironically, often exacerbates this challenge. Larger organizations with greater complexity face more entrenched silos, not fewer.

From Vision to Value: How Leading Teams Operationalize AI

Despite the friction, a growing cohort of forward-looking CS teams are achieving meaningful results with AI, not by chasing novelty, but by embedding intelligence into existing motion. Here are three use cases gaining traction:

1. AI-Drafted QBR Usage Summaries (19%): Teams are leveraging AI to generate clean, contextual usage narratives, reducing manual preparation and elevating the quality of executive business reviews.
2. Next-Best-Action Recommendations (17%): Behavior-based task suggestions are helping CSMs move from reactive follow-up to proactive engagement—delivered directly within their current toolset.
3. Predictive Churn Indicators (14%): Rather than waiting for lagging red flags, these teams are surfacing early churn signals and intervening when it matters most.

The common thread across these examples? Each initiative is deeply integrated into the CS team’s daily workflow. These are not dashboards to check; they are actions delivered in the flow of work.

Through the use of AI, we reduced time on renewals and churn reporting by over 30 hours, freeing our team to engage customers strategically. | Jeremy Donaldson, Customer Success Leader at LifeLoop

{{benchmarks-report}}

The Infrastructure-First Approach: What Sets Breakthrough Teams Apart

What separates teams that scale AI from those that stall is not experimentation—but preparation. Successful initiatives are built on three core foundations:

1. Unified Data Architecture
   A consolidated view of customer behavior, support history, and business outcomes—stitched across systems—is the starting point. Without it, AI cannot see clearly enough to act meaningfully.
2. Embedded Intelligence
   Effective AI does not sit in isolation. It is woven into playbooks, customer portals, and the very tools that teams already use. If it’s not visible in the workflow, it’s not driving value.
3. Outcome-Driven Measurement
   The goal is not to be “AI-powered,” but to achieve measurable improvements: hours saved, churn reduced, workflows adopted. Framing AI success through operational KPIs keeps focus on what matters.

A Global Snapshot: Shared Struggles, Divergent Priorities

While challenges persist across geographies, regional nuance plays a role:

• EMEA: 16% of CS teams report having no AI plans at all, often citing data infrastructure readiness as the primary barrier.
• North America: Adoption is more experimental, but often constrained by compliance concerns and organizational risk aversion.

Yet beneath these differences lies a shared realization: more tools will not fix broken systems. AI success is not defined by investment alone, but by readiness.

Strategic Reflections: Questions Every CS Leader Should Be Asking

• Are we measuring AI success by usage rates—or by the outcomes it enables for our customers?
• Do our systems talk to each other, or are we managing disconnected silos?
• What does personalization truly mean in our customer journey—and can AI realistically support that vision?

Looking Ahead: Readiness Is the Real Differentiator

The organizations that will lead in AI-powered customer success are not those with the largest budgets or the most aggressive vendor rosters. They are those that understand the real equation:
‍
✨ AI doesn’t scale personalization. Data readiness does. ✨

{{cta-demo2}}

If personalization is the promise, data is the foundation.
If AI is the engine, workflows are the steering wheel.
You need both.

As Alexandra Sagaydak, Chief Customer Officer at PeopleForce, put it:

‍If I could add one capability in 2025, it’d be AI-driven journey orchestration, so every customer path feels handcrafted, not hardcoded.

This aspiration for orchestrated, personalized journeys isn’t just theoretical, it's being brought to life by forward-thinking teams. At Spryker, for example, the Customer Success team introduced a unified customer interface to align onboarding, success plans, and key milestones in one shared space. The results were striking: a 30% reduction in time-to-value and a 2x increase in customer satisfaction scores. More importantly, the interface became a medium of trust, where both sides could see progress, anticipate next steps, and operate with mutual clarity.

This kind of enablement signals a broader shift in mindset: AI may generate insights, but it’s the surrounding infrastructure—the data, workflows, and shared visibility, that makes those insights actionable. The future won’t be defined by the tools teams buy, but by how seamlessly those tools empower customers to move forward, confidently and collaboratively.

Coming Soon: Part 3 of the 2025 CX Benchmark Series

Why 68% of CS teams still rely on spreadsheets for onboarding—and what’s finally changing in 2025.

📥 Want access to the full 2025 Digital Customer Success Benchmark report? Let us know, and we’ll share the full findings.