5 Lessons from Failing Customer Success Programs

5 Lessons from Failing Customer Success Programs5 Lessons from Failing Customer Success Programs

Customer success can’t just be another checkbox—it’s a powerful driver for growth when woven into a company’s culture and aligned with core goals. This article dives into five critical lessons from failed customer success programs, from fostering true cross-department collaboration to using data insights strategically. Discover how to build a resilient, proactive approach that makes every customer interaction count. Ready to learn from these key failings and turn them into wins? Let’s get started.

Don't try to define customer success in isolation, instead align goals with all departments

In the software industry, having different departments work in isolation can result in a lack of cohesion in customer success efforts. When customer success objectives are aligned with the larger goals of the company, it's possible to achieve service delivery that is both consistent and effective.

"Customer success should not be viewed as a standalone operation but as a core component of the entire business strategy."
— Real Individual

A significant insight is that customer success should integrate with broader organizational strategies. That means that instead of functioning as an isolated unit, the customer success team collaborates closely with sales, marketing, and product development; the teams set shared objectives, use common metrics, and all pull together to improve the customer's journey through the company and the experience at the end of that journey.

Tip: Regular interactions, joint planning sessions, and shared platforms for customer data enable teams to understand each other's activities and challenges, preventing inefficiencies and ensuring a seamless customer experience.


Achieving alignment among various functions at a company is primarily a communication challenge. To work well together, the functions must understand one another's activities and the particular challenges each faces. This understanding dawns most readily and surely through frequent interaction. Regular interactions, joint planning sessions, and shared platforms for customer data enable teams to understand each other's activities and challenges, preventing inefficiencies and ensuring a seamless customer experience. This alignment supports proactive customer engagement—anticipating needs rather than just responding to them—leading to improved customer satisfaction and retention rates.

In short, a comprehensive, company-wide customer success directive reaps substantial advantages. When a corporation opts for "customer success" instead of "customer support," and when it actualizes the concept of customer success both collaboratively and correspondingly across the whole firm, then not only does the corporation meet customer needs effectively, but it also profits from a sustainable growth model over the long term.

A serene office environment with a diverse group of smiling professionals collaborating over a table filled with laptops and charts, surrounded by plants and natural light, conveying a sense of teamwork and positivity.

Don't try to treat customer success as a side initiative, instead institutionalize it as a culture

When companies view customer success as a sideshow, they inevitably lose out on the key benefits of embedding it into their organizational culture. They miss the pivotal point that customer success has to be worked into the very DNA of a company for it to function as a core value. The only way for customer success to be part of the core value conversation is for it to be part of the top-down and bottom-up conversation—working its way, like the company grapevine, into every corner of the organization.

Fact: Companies may experience a 20% to 30% uplift in customer satisfaction when focusing significantly on customer-oriented practices.


A customer-centric culture is broader than a department or a team. It is spread far and wide across an organization, integrating customer-centric principles into all business functions—from product development and marketing to sales and support. A shift to this kind of culture is not easy and requires a long-term commitment. Companies that have made this shift do not see it as a program or initiative but rather as a new way of working together. At Zappos, for instance, here's how our guys in Customer Loyalty might explain their work to someone not quite in the know: "We focus on building relationships and understanding our customers’ needs to foster loyalty."

The customer success movement's executive leadership seems to be right where it needs to be at present, leading businesses toward the core of that movement. Cross-functional collaboration is now much more the rule than the exception, breaking down silos and producing more coherent customer experiences. For many organizations, this is much more than a nice-sounding, superficial change. It's about setting, as leaders tend to do, team ethos expectations and integrating both customer-focused metrics (which are often huge steps forward for organizations) and "succeed together" narratives into performance appraisals that really mean something.

McKinsey's Harald Fanderl emphasized, “There is no silver bullet—only a holistic approach will succeed.”

What this underscores is that fostering a customer-centric culture takes not just operational and IT improvements but also requires a fundamental shift in mindset across one's organization. If such change is wrought, a smattering of benefits is likely to accrue; for instance, one might note that businesses may experience a 20% to 30% uplift in customer satisfaction when focusing significantly on customer-oriented practices.

Completing this journey of transformation depends on building a network of internal champions who can back the vision and keep change moving along. The journey is seldom easy, but when leaders salute the key milestones and build a sense of team around the accomplishment of those milestones, they create a work environment that drives everyone toward the newly defined target. While not every organization achieves this total alignment, even at the top and bottom levels, the closer any organization gets to this in every tier, the more chance it has of ensuring that everyone is working on the same definition of success.

Don't try to manage customer success without proper resources, instead establish and empower a dedicated customer success team

It's essential for software companies that want to boost customer loyalty and retention to have a full team and proper resources dedicated solely to the customer success function. Attempts to manage this function while also managing customer support and sales—without real resources and a committed team—are likely to yield mediocre results. On the other hand, distinguishing the customer success function and allocating resources to it can lead to much better results and a lot more happy customers.

Tip: Establishing a dedicated customer success team at your company can lead to significantly enhanced customer relationships and loyalty.


Establishing a customer success team begins with a well-defined mission that underscores its distinctive function in the organization. This, as emphasized by industry experts, is not merely an expansion of traditional support roles; rather, it is building a proactive, knowledgeable partnership that trusts to anticipate the directions the customer's business is likely to take and aligns your resources with theirs. The longer the relationship continues, the more likely both parties are to share the same vocabulary and mental map of the business landscape.

"Helps build a company’s brand."

The importance of having a specialized team is underscored by Forbes, which describes the function of such a team in leading customers through the various stages of their journey and ensuring they are getting the most value possible from a product or service. This not only delights the customer and makes them more likely to stick around, but also helps build a company’s brand.

In addition, it is vital to form a dedicated team if an organization is to avoid falling into any number of common traps—like becoming inefficient or unfocused. As a result, it is necessary to empower a Customer Success Operations team to solve complex and important problems. At the same time, this foundation allows the organization to channel precious resources in a much better, more thoughtful direction and, in so doing, again create an environment far more conducive to both customer success and company success.

To achieve excellence in customer success, software companies must have a dedicated team driving their efforts. In customer success, much like in product management, a key risk to avoid is "projectitis"—the tendency to lapse into a mindset where you define success by whether or not you hit key performance indicators (KPIs) tied to specific projects.

Don't try to work in silos, instead promote adaptability and cross-departmental collaboration

A vibrant office space with diverse teams collaborating at a large table, colorful charts and documents scattered around, a plant in the corner, and a window showing a bright skyline. Everyone is smiling, engaged in discussion, and not looking at the camera.

Accomplishment in customer programs in the software industry often requires adaptability and collaboration across departments. It is not enough to break down silos—organizations must cultivate a culture of flexibility and teamwork if they want to nurture cross-departmental collaboration. The alignment that should exist between sales, marketing, product, and operations to serve the customer cannot be achieved if these departments operate anywhere near independently. Giving them all a ‘customer-first’ mentality helps.

Integrated approaches yield significant improvements. For instance, recent studies reveal that well-aligned teams can generate over 208% more revenue from marketing activities. This statistic underscores the collaboration-boosting effect of these modern integrated approaches. And those approaches have to be effective because, within the scheme of customer experience, the alignment of sales and customer success is prologue to the even greater experience generated by an integrated account team.

"Customer insights can be shared among teams in a way that allows them to work with the kind of intelligence that makes for lean, mean, customer-success machines."
— Real Individual

Fact: Teams with strong cross-departmental collaboration can achieve over 208% more revenue from their marketing activities.


Using tools that consolidate data and guarantee open communication can boost customer satisfaction, as emphasized by comparing well-integrated platforms.

A joined-up approach is further enhanced by frequent cross-functional meetings, where we can talk about what we do and how we do it; by shared departmental goals that allow us to synchronize our departmental symphony; and by training initiatives that cultivate understanding—and, dare I say, good, old-fashioned empathy—between the teams that are working so closely together.

This is a 360-degree strategy for breaking down silos, reinforcing shared responsibility, and leading towards innovation and exceptional customer value.

Recommended reading:

Don't try to guess customer needs, instead harness the right tools and analytics

A vibrant office space filled with modern technology tools, showcasing a large screen displaying analytics data. A diverse group of smiling professionals collaborates around a table, engaged in a positive discussion, surrounded by charts and graphs on the walls.

Grasping the demands of customers is fundamental to creating successful customer success programs. It doesn't matter if your assumptions are well-intentioned; they can still lead to missteps and even failure. In every customer interaction, valuable data is created. Capturing this information using the correct tools of the trade enables businesses to work without the safety net of guesswork. They can now base their strategies and programs upon real, actionable insights.

Tip: Use platforms like Hotjar for session recordings or Google Analytics to gain insights into user behaviors and preferences.


The latest developments in data collection have turned into a revolution software companies use to gauge the effectiveness of their customer success programs. With the means to collect and analyze a nearly limitless amount of data, not only are these companies gaining a deeper understanding of who their customers are, but also of what their customers really want. And as that understanding grows, so too does the knowledge of the "why" behind certain customer behaviors. For instance, platforms like Hotjar’s session recordings reveal user navigation patterns, while Google Analytics helps identify key trends impacting customer journeys.

Software firms are using integrated systems to handle the many facets of customer interactions. They are turning to a journey orchestration platform, which unifies data from many sources into a cohesive view of the customer experience. Orchestration expedites the identification of customer journey friction points and, as a result, amplifies Customer Satisfaction (CSAT) scores.

By employing diverse and robust tools, such as EverAfter’s customer interface, software companies can implement personalized solutions that address specific needs and preferences. This data-driven mindset transforms how companies approach customer success, ensuring they stay competitive in an ever-evolving market.

“Using comprehensive analytics isn’t just about collecting data; it's about transforming that data into meaningful actions.”
— EverAfter’s leadership team

FAQ

How can aligning customer success goals with other departments benefit a company in the software sector?

When customer success and other departments have aligned goals, the newly aligned departments are able to serve the customer in a unified, consistent manner. It isn't just that the departments are now working toward the same end—they are now also working toward the same set of metrics, which allows for a kind of symphonic customer service that is increasingly rare in the business world.

Why is it important to institutionalize customer success as a culture rather than treating it as a side initiative?

The customer success field centers around a single core idea: that a company can only truly be successful if its customers are also succeeding. Our goal, your goal, is to set customers on a path to long-term success with the product—and to make that scalable. The "product" could be a software solution, a services and consulting business, or some other entity. In any event, the culture of customer success is predicated on the notion that if customers aren't getting what they want from your offering, they're not going to stay around for long.

What role does a dedicated customer success team play in a company?

The customer success team is key to building strong customer relationships. This team anticipates what customers will need and smoothly aligns what the company offers to meet those needs. The team, with its customer-first philosophy, ensures that the company not only retains customers but also delights them—all while enhancing the company’s brand.

How does cross-departmental collaboration enhance customer programs?

When teams across departments work together, they foster a culture of putting the customer first. And since there’s no greater authority on the subject of the customer than the people on the front lines, the next best thing to direct interaction is to work hand-in-hand with those who do.

Why is it important for businesses to use the right tools and analytics in customer success programs?

The correct instruments and analysis permit companies to seize from their customers interactions the precious data that let them figure out what strategy to adopt, far removed from basing decisions on hunches. This intelligence almost inverts the data-work cycle we've been using and allows companies to serve their customers with much more relevance and predict what will happen next.

BOOK A DEMO
EverAfter Virtual Conference 2023
September 13th, 2023
Save your spot today

Ready to see a personalized demo?

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

You may also like…

5 Lessons from Failing Customer Success Programs
Download now
Check it out

Ready to see a personalized demo?

By clicking “Accept”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy for more information.